Become a Best partner Swap to NZ
Experience Italy at the Best Italian Restaurants in Sydney
Published 26 October 2023

Dreaming of sipping an Aperol spritz on the Amalfi Coast or twirling pasta in a cosy trattoria in Rome?.  At Best Restaurants, we'll guide you through the culinary gems that will whisk you away to Italy with every delicious bite. From authentic Neapolitan pizzas to homemade gnocchi, this selection of the best Italian restaurants will make you feel like you're dining in the heart of Italy, all while enjoying that classic Aussie hospitality.

Don't forget to visit our full guide to the BEST ITALIAN RESTAURANTS.

  • Matteo Double Bay

    29 Bay Street, Double Bay
    This buzzy neighbourhood trattoria brings a slice of the Amalfi Coast to Double Bay with a sun-drenched courtyard, vacation-chic decor and a menu inspired by the Capania coastline. The spicy vodka rigatoni is a genuine cult obsession.
    Read more
    Buy a gift card for Matteo Double Bay Buy
  • Ormeggio at The Spit

    D'Albora Marinas, The Spit, Spit Road, Mosman
    A long Italian lunch overlooking the sparkling waters of Pearl Bay is enough to cure any travel FOMO. This trattoria combines a million-dollar view with stellar cocktails, a gelato bar and sustainable seafood plates. Boating for the day? Have their sister venue, Chiosoco, look after the catering. Simply place your order and collect between 8.30am–11am from the kiosk window.
    Read more
    Buy a gift card for Ormeggio at The Spit Buy
  • Pilu at Freshwater

    Moore Rd, Freshwater

    Pilu at Freshwater is an award-winning Italian restaurant set against the beautiful backdrop of Freshwater beach. The light and airy space, framed by big bay windows, allows patrons to enjoy the seaside views whilst tucking into the thrilling taste of Sardinia. The restaurant aesthetic has a laid-back beach vibe doused in baby blue hues, crisp white finishes, and rustic wooden floorboards. With views looking directly out onto the ocean, it is easy to be swept away by the majesty of the natural realm.

     

    Lunch Wednesday to Sunday and dinner Wednesday to Saturday

    Read more
    Buy a gift card for Pilu at Freshwater Buy
  • Pellegrino 2000

    80 Campbell St, Surry Hills

    Located in a terrace house in Surry Hills, close to the Sydney CBD, Pellegrino's is inspired by the trattorias of Italy, with warm lighting and white tablecloths. There is a rustic touch with walls lined with wine bottles, tins of tomatoes, bottles of olive oil and photos. Expect traditional dishes like parpadelle bolognaise, long-simmered pork + veal and ravioli gamberi with burnt butter sauce. The wine list features classic Italian wines like Chianti with a few Australian and French to choose from.

     

    Open for lunch Friday-Saturday and dinner daily

    Read more
  • Machiavelli Ristorante Italiano

    123 Clarence Street,, Sydney CBD

    With handmade pasta; ravioli, gnocchi and traditional Italian fare, Machiavelli has been producing true Italian flavours befitting its famous name for 30 years. Explore a menu of fresh antipasti, handmade pasta adorned with seafood straight from the Sydney Fish markets. Boasting an impressive wine selection from the best wineries of Italy, Australia and New Zealand, diners are truly spoilt for choice. Perfect for an intimate dining experience or an impressive corporate function, Machiavelli caters to all occasions.

    Read more
    Buy a gift card for Machiavelli Ristorante Italiano Buy
  • OTTO Ristorante

    6 Cowper Wharf Road, Woolloomooloo Wharf, Woolloomooloo

    Situated in the spectacular surrounds of the Finger Wharf at Woolloomooloo, OTTO has an undeniable reputation as one of Sydney's most respected dining institutions. The food at OTTO is delicious and unashamedly simple modern Italian with roots firmly placed in the classics. Head Chef Richard Ptacnik's menu is fresh, seasonal and produce-driven; sourcing the finest ingredients and letting them speak for themselves. When you dine at OTTO, you are truly living la dolce vita.

     

    Read more
    Buy a gift card for OTTO Ristorante Buy
  • Alberto's Lounge

    17-19 Alberta Street, Sydney CBD

    Blink and you’ll miss Alberto’s Lounge, hidden down a nondescript street, this Italian restaurant is making its mark on Sydney’s food scene. The majority of the restaurant is reserved for walk-ins so join the queue, grab a glass of wine and work up an appetite. With former 10 William Street chef Dan Pepperell behind the pots and pans, it’s little surprise that the menu at Alberto’s Lounge is kicking goals however it’s more Italian- Australian than true Italian, in the best possible way. T

    Read more
  • Capriccio Osteria

    159 Norton Street, Leichhardt
    There’s an authentic, unpretentious feel to this neighbourhood osteria owned by Positano native Michele Rispoli, with its Tuscan-style courtyard and bar brimming with retro Italian crockery. Its handmade pastas – particularly the squid ink spaghetti, made with blue swimmer crab, chilli and basil – are the stuff of Mediterranean dreams.
    Read more
    Buy a gift card for Capriccio Osteria Buy
  • Buon Ricordo

    108 Boundary Street, Paddington

    This restaurant is aptly named "good memories," which is exactly what diners have been taking away from Buon Ricordo since it opened its Paddington doors in 1987. Today, waiters in trim white jackets fuss over patrons who sample the glory of classical Italian hospitality. The cuisine is traditional, with authentic Italian flavours and techniques on display. The wine list is Italian-based to round off your European dining experience.

    Read more
  • Cipri Italian

    10 Elizabeth Street, Paddington

    The Cipri brothers are well-known among Sydney foodies and their latest restaurant, Cipri Italian, is another great eatery to add to their repertoire. Combing the extravagance of Milan and the taste of Tuscany, Cipri brings together the very best of Italian style, along with an atmosphere that welcomes fashionistas, families and everyone in between. The restaurant is available for functions for up to 85 guests seated and there is street-side parking, which is a bonus for this area.

    Read more
  • Il Baretto

    338 Oxford Street, Paddington

    Make a bee-line to Il Baretto restaurant in Paddington, where lip-smacking good Italian fare compels the punters to wait it out for a coveted seat. The restaurant offers an assortment of specials changing fortnightly (take a peek at the giant paper menu attached to the wall). This is simple Italian cookery at its best.

    Read more

You may also like